Help! My Cat’s a Fussy Eater! What Can I Do?

Following on from our recent blogpost about children who are picky eaters, we look next at another related topic.

If you’re the devoted servant of a cat who turns their nose up at dinner more often than not, you’re not alone. 

Fussy eating is a common trait among our feline friends, and it can be a source of frustration and concern for pet owners. 

Fortunately, there are plenty of practical options and tips available to help coax your picky eater into enjoying mealtimes again.

Why Are Some Cats So Picky?

Cats are creatures of habit and routine, and many are sensitive to changes in food texture, smell, temperature, or flavour. A fussy cat might be reacting to:

Past negative experiences with certain foods

Boredom with the same food every day

Health issues (always worth checking with your vet)

Dislike of particular textures (e.g. chunks in jelly vs. pâté)

Our cat hates the taste of duck. Loves chicken, hates duck.

Tried and Tested Solutions for Fussy Cats

1. Rule Out Health Problems

First and foremost, if your cat suddenly becomes fussy or stops eating, get them checked by your vet. Dental problems, digestive issues, or other illnesses can all affect appetite.

2. Experiment with Different Textures

Some cats prefer mousse-style food, while others like gravy or jelly. Dry kibble might appeal more to some, especially if it’s crunchy and fresh-smelling.

Top tip: Try offering small samples of different food textures to find what your cat enjoys most.

3. Warm It Up

Warming your cat’s wet food slightly (just a few seconds in the microwave) can enhance the aroma and make it more tempting. Just be sure it’s not too hot.

4. Add a Topper

A sprinkle of freeze-dried chicken, tuna flakes, or even a splash of warm low-salt chicken broth can make an ordinary meal far more enticing.

5. Offer Variety (But Not Too Much)

Cats can become bored with the same food every day, so rotating between a few favourite flavours or brands can help. However, too much variety might lead to a cat becoming more fussy, always expecting something new!

6. Stick to a Schedule

Leaving food down all day can lead to grazing and disinterest. Try set mealtimes and remove uneaten food after 20–30 minutes. Your cat will learn to eat when food is offered. Food left out all day during hot weather can spoil, so be aware of that. 

7. Create a Calm Eating Environment

Some cats are sensitive to noise, other pets, or even humans hovering too close during mealtimes. A quiet, stress-free feeding area can encourage more relaxed eating.

8. Try Puzzle Feeders

For dry food lovers, puzzle feeders can make meals more stimulating and rewarding. It mimics hunting behaviour and can encourage interest in food.

When All Else Fails

If your cat is consistently rejecting multiple foods, your vet may suggest:

A prescription appetite stimulant

A prescription diet for cats with food sensitivities or health issues

Blood tests to rule out thyroid issues, kidney problems, or allergies

Living with a fussy feline can be a bit of a challenge, but with patience, observation, and a few clever tricks, you can usually find a feeding routine that works. Every cat is an individual, some may always be a bit particular, but they’re worth the effort (even if you do end up being their personal chef!).